Buy Existing or Build New?

Most people have ideals for their dream home. A gas fireplace in the living room, a vaulted ceiling in the primary bedroom, an island with seating in the kitchen, etc. Chances are they’ve lived in a few homes that were less than ideal and now they want the “dream” home.

What is best? Buy an existing home or build a new home?

There are several factors to consider. First, we’ll look at buying an existing home.

1. Unique Design. When you buy an existing home you have options of homes through all decades, from historic homes to more recent builds. This allows you to look for any style home from a bilevel to a bungalow to a cape cod to a colonial and so on.

2. Renovations May Be Needed. Unless the owners have done a lot of work, most older homes are outdated and need renovations. Often fresh paint and new flooring are a priority. Some homes may need kitchen and bathroom makeovers, which are extensive and expensive.

3. Repairs May Be Required. Depending upon the age of the home, and what the owner has done, older homes typically require more repairs and maintenance. The home may need a new roof or HVAC, or it may need the electric and plumbing upgraded, etc. Repairs can be costly if there are “big ticket” items that need to be replaced.

4. Ideal Location and Lot. If choosing an existing home, you will have more options for the location and lot size. New builds are typically in communities with smaller size lots and could also have an HOA. An existing home gives you more choices to find that home by the woods with a private backyard, or in a neighborhood you love.

5. Mature Landscaping. If you love big trees and always imagined a park-like setting for your backyard, an existing home may be the better option. New construction means new plantings while an older home is more likely to have beautiful trees, bushes, and beds. 

Now let’s look at building a new home.

1. Everything is New. This is one of the most desirable pros about building a new home. Everything is brand new – the roof, HVAC, electrical and plumbing. The home has been built to the latest codes and there has been no “retrofitting” or add ons. Typically this means years and years of no repairs.

2. Modern Design. There’s nothing outdated on a new build! Color choices and styling, both inside and outside, reflect current trends. If you’re willing to pay for upgrades, you can get high-end finishes and customize your look.

3. Energy Efficient. New homes are built with energy savings in mind. Vinyl windows, doors and trim all help keep the home air tight. Better insulation and other construction materials help keep a home’s temperature moderated to save on energy bills.

4. Planned Timeline. When building a new home, you will have a fairly solid timeline for the completion. This allows you to begin preparing to move, knowing exactly where and when you are moving. Unlike existing homes where you are watching the market and running to multiple showings, you choose your home and begin the process.

5. Restrictive HOAs. A new community often has governing HOA rules. Some of these are lenient while others can be very restrictive, even down to the color of siding allowed. This is important to consider if you want to one day build a pool, or need to park a work vehicle in your driveway.

Buying an existing home or building a new one is really up to the type of home you love. An old home can be made beautiful with time and money. New construction can often be more expensive upfront but will give you years of easy living. 

If you have any questions about the process of buying and renovating a home, or what it’s like to build a new home, please reach out. I’m always happy to help!

YOU MIGHT ALSO ENJOY

Holiday Lights and Local Delights

December has a way of making our towns feel a little more magical. From twinkling lights to cheerful markets and cozy small businesses, this time of year reminds us why Lancaster County and its surrounding communities are such special places to call home. Whether you’re new to the area, a long-time local, or exploring neighborhoods as you consider a move, here are some of the best ways to enjoy the season.

A Season for Gratitude: Five Reasons to be Thankful for Your Home

As the season of gratitude settles in, it’s a wonderful time to pause and appreciate the place we call home. Our homes hold our memories, protect us from the world, and offer comfort at the beginning and end of each day. Yet it’s easy to forget how significant that blessing is, especially when so many people across the country don’t have stable housing at all.
Here are five heartfelt reminders that help us reflect on just how much we have to be thankful for.

The Pitfalls of Overpricing Your Home

When it’s time to sell your home, it’s natural to want the best possible price. There are many reasons why overpricing negatively affects your home sale. But setting the price too high—hoping to “test the market” or leave room for negotiation—can actually hurt your sale in ways many homeowners don’t expect. Let’s take a look at the main reasons why.

Listing As-Is: When It Makes Sense

Sometimes, selling a home feels like a race against time, and the last thing you want to do is spend time and money on renovations. Maybe your home needs updates or has a lot of deferred maintenance. Maybe your situation calls for a simple sale. That’s where listing as-is comes in.
Does it actually make sense for you to sell this way? What should you keep in mind before you do? Let’s walk through the details.